Contractor Club
A contractor reviewing and comparing multiple construction contract documents at a desk under warm directional lighting with golden tones
Pricing & Bidding

Types of Construction Contracts: Which One Makes You the Most Money

Mo El Hadri
Stories by Mo El Hadri
@mointhemarket·7 November 2026·7 min read

Most contractors accept whatever contract the client puts in front of them without questioning the structure. The price, yes - they negotiate hard on that. The contract type itself? Almost never. That is the wrong end of the deal to be fighting over.

The types of construction contracts in front of you determine how risk is split between you and the client. Get it wrong and you are carrying costs you should not be. Get it right and your margin is protected before anyone lifts a tool. (Figures in USD - the model and the math are identical in any currency.)

And this is really a conversation about construction arbitrage - taking a fixed price from the client, instructing your subs on a different basis, and keeping the spread. Understanding contract types is what makes that work. General contractor (main contractor in the UK), call it what you like - this is the model.

The five main types of construction contracts

There are five contract structures you will encounter across residential, commercial and public sector work. Each one splits financial risk differently between you and the client.

Contract typeWho carries the riskBest forMargin protection
Lump sum (fixed price)ContractorWell-defined scopeHigh if you price it right
Cost-plusClientUnknown or evolving scopeTransparent - client sees your fee
Time and materialsClientSmall jobs, emergency workLow - no efficiency premium
Guaranteed maximum price (GMP)SplitCommercial projects, fast-trackCapped upside, some downside risk
Unit price / re-measurementSplitCivil, groundworks, infrastructurePredictable per unit, quantity risk remains

Lump sum (fixed price) contracts

One price. One scope. You deliver the finished project for the agreed amount. If it costs you less than expected, you keep the difference. If it costs more, you absorb it. This is the contract type most residential clients expect and most contractors default to.

The upside is clarity - and privacy. The client knows what they are paying. You know what you are building. When you have fully scoped the job and priced it accurately, the lump sum protects your margin better than any other structure, because there is no mechanism for the client to scrutinise what your subs are costing you.

The risk: scope creep and hidden conditions. If the client adds to the scope mid-project without a formal change order, you absorb extra work for free. If you open a wall and find structural issues that were not in the drawings, that surprise is yours. Lump sum contracts require a thorough scope document, a clear exclusions list, and a disciplined change order process. Without those three, the fixed price works against you.

Cost-plus contracts

The client pays your actual project costs - labour, materials, plant, subcontractors - plus a negotiated fee. If the job runs over because of conditions that could not be anticipated, the client pays. The main advantage for you is that unexpected cost increases are not yours to absorb.

The disadvantage is transparency. The client has visibility into what everything costs. That changes the conversation. On a lump sum, your margin is private. On cost-plus, the client can see exactly how much you are charging over cost - and that invites scrutiny. Some clients will push for open-book accounting: every invoice and purchase order on the table.

Cost-plus makes sense when the scope genuinely cannot be defined before work starts: renovations with unknown structural conditions, phased commercial fit-outs, projects where the design is evolving alongside construction. If you are running a construction arbitrage operation, cost-plus from your client combined with competitive quotes from your subs still gives you a margin. You are the manager. The fee is the arbitrage.

Time and materials contracts

You bill your hours at an agreed rate and your materials at cost or with a markup. No fixed price. No scope document. Bill as you go. This sounds like easy money. It is not.

Time and materials works for small repair and maintenance jobs where writing a full scope and quote would take longer than the work itself - emergency callouts, reactive maintenance, small punch-list items. For anything larger, you lose two things: the efficiency premium and predictability. On a lump sum, if you finish in less time than you priced, you keep the saving. On T&M, you bill exactly what you used. There is no premium for being fast.

The practical problem on T&M is client pushback when the bill arrives. Even clients who agreed to T&M will challenge line items if the total surprises them. Getting paid faster starts with weekly billing on T&M jobs. Never let it run to month end when the total has crept up and the client has forgotten what they said yes to.

Guaranteed maximum price (GMP) contracts

GMP is a hybrid. You run it like cost-plus - client pays actuals plus fee - but you agree upfront that the total will not exceed a stated maximum. If costs breach the cap, you carry the overrun. If they come in under the GMP, the contract specifies what happens to the saving: sometimes the client keeps it all, sometimes it is shared between both parties.

GMP became common in commercial construction because it gives the client some certainty while allowing the design to develop alongside construction. For the contractor, it creates a one-sided ceiling: your upside is capped, but your downside is not fully protected. The critical discipline is setting the GMP with enough contingency that you are not constantly fighting to stay under it. A GMP that is squeezed tight before construction starts is a contract waiting to become a dispute.

Unit price (re-measurement) contracts

Common in civil engineering, groundworks and infrastructure: you agree a price per unit of work, and the final contract value is determined by the actual quantity completed. Per metre of pipe laid. Per cubic yard of excavation. Per linear foot of kerbing. You carry the risk of your rate being wrong. The client carries the risk of quantity being different from the initial estimate.

Unit price works when the type of work is predictable but the exact quantity is not known until site conditions are exposed. For general contractors using the construction arbitrage model, unit price from the main client can pair with day rate from your subs: you know your per-unit margin, your subs know their daily rate, and the spread between those two numbers is your business.

Which contract type works best if you are running the arbitrage model?

Here is the structure that protects your margin: take a lump sum or GMP from your client, priced to include your management fee and a contingency. Instruct your subcontractors on day rates or time and materials in scopes they know well. The subs quote or work in known conditions. You have already priced the spread into the top-line contract. The difference between what your client pays and what your subs cost is your business.

This is not a secret. It is how every general contractor has always run. The client does not need to know the breakdown - they hired you to deliver the project. What they care about is the finished result on time and to cost. Pricing the job correctly at the front end is what makes this work. The markup you apply has to cover your overhead, your subs' inefficiencies, and your profit - before the site starts.

If you are writing the contract yourself, or reviewing one a client has sent you, the type tells you immediately where the risk sits. Understand it and you can negotiate the terms that matter. Ignore it and you are signing up to costs and risks you have not priced.

They see the price. They don't see the spread. The spread is the business.

@mointhemarket

If you want to understand how to structure your contracts so the margin stays yours - and build a business that runs on a network of reliable subs rather than your own labour - Contractor Club is built for exactly that.

Request entry to Contractor Club⟶
ShareXWhatsAppLinkedIn

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common type of construction contract?+

In residential construction, the lump sum (fixed price) contract is the most common. The client agrees to pay a fixed amount for a defined scope of work. In commercial and public sector projects, cost-plus and GMP contracts are more widely used because the scope is often developed as the project progresses.

What is the difference between a lump sum and a fixed price contract?+

They are the same thing. Lump sum and fixed price both describe a contract where the contractor agrees to complete a defined scope of work for one agreed total. The term varies by region and by which standard form of contract is used - AIA forms in the USA, JCT forms in the UK, AS 4000 in Australia.

What is a GMP in construction?+

GMP stands for Guaranteed Maximum Price. It is a type of cost-plus contract where the contractor agrees that the total project cost will not exceed a stated maximum. The client pays actual costs plus a fee, up to the cap. If costs come in under the GMP, the contract will specify what happens to the saving - sometimes the client keeps it, sometimes it is shared between client and contractor.

When should a contractor use cost-plus instead of a lump sum?+

When the scope is genuinely unknown at the start of the project. Renovations, fit-outs, and projects with high uncertainty in ground conditions or hidden works are common candidates. With a lump sum, you are carrying all the risk of unknowns. With cost-plus, that risk sits with the client. The tradeoff is that the client has more visibility into your costs and fees.

Can I use a different contract type with my subcontractors than I use with my client?+

Yes - and this is exactly how smart general contractors manage their risk. You take a lump sum from the client, priced to include your margin, and you instruct your subs on day rates or time and materials. The difference between what your client pays and what your subs cost is your margin. The client does not need to know what structure you use with your subs.

What is a unit price construction contract?+

In a unit price contract, the client pays a fixed rate per unit of work completed - per metre of trench, per cubic yard of excavation, per door installed. The final cost depends on the actual quantity, which is measured after the work. This type is common in civil, groundworks and infrastructure projects where the type of work is known but the exact quantities may vary.

The human behind The Playbook

Go deeper

Learn the model, then get in the room

The full breakdown of construction arbitrage lives on our sister site, constructionarbitrage.com. When you want the operators who actually run it, join the Construction Arbitrage Players community.

My listening book THE EDGE is out now - 24 chapters on how the money really moves through a contracting business, made to be listened to on the drive. Free to start. See what is inside.

My book The Family Secret - how construction arbitrage really works - is coming soon.

Only Players Know

The game is real. The room is closed.

Contractor Club is a private, application-only circle of construction arbitrage operators. If you think you belong inside, apply and the circle will decide.

More from the Playbook

View all ⟶